Navigating a first round executive interview requires a blend of strategic insight, genuine self-presentation and thorough preparation. As someone pursuing a high-level role, this is your chance to demonstrate not only your professional expertise but also your ability to forge strong connections.
Your LinkedIn® profile, personal narrative and pre-interview planning can all create a powerful impression, setting you apart as a compelling candidate.
This essay will walk you through key aspects of executive interview preparation, from optimising your online presence to confidently sharing your story and building rapport. The assumption is made that you are having an 'in-person' panel interview - online panel interviews will be discussed in a later essay but many of the same points will apply.
1. Embrace Authenticity: Be Yourself
One of the most important aspects of any executive interview is being genuine. In leadership positions, authenticity is not just refreshing; it is essential. High-level hiring managers are looking for people they can trust to lead, inspire and represent their organisation. Resist the urge to be overly formal or to deliver tremendously rehearsed responses. Instead, approach the interview as an opportunity to engage in an insightful conversation where you reveal your unique perspective, story and values.
Authenticity builds credibility and that credibility is key for executives.
2. Optimise Your LinkedIn® Profile: Visibility and Impact
As an executive, your LinkedIn® profile is often the first place an interviewer / recruiter / employer / consultant will look. Optimise your profile to reflect your expertise, achievements and leadership style. Be sure that your profile headline, summary and recent accomplishments are up-to-date and engaging. Highlight the strategic results you have driven in previous roles and the impact you have had on teams, projects and organisations.
Please review any posts, shared content and comments you make on LinkedIn® (and all other open social media platforms) from the perspective of the interviewer / employer’s representative. If there is anything that can be misconstrued, view in a negative light or in any way negatively impact their view of you, please consider its relevance to your story.
When preparing for your interview, use LinkedIn® to research the people who will be involved in your interview. Review their professional journeys, recent projects or articles they have shared. This will give you insight into their professional style and personality – you may discover something you have in common, which may in turn give you something of interest to discuss if there is a pause during the interview conversation. Further to this you will (hopefully they will have an open professional headshot on their profile) also be a to put ‘a face to the name’, removing that stress when you meet them.
Resist the temptation to connect with these folk before the interview. Instead, save this for after you have met, as an intentional follow-up that continues the connection and reinforces your professional interest.
3. Share Your Story: The STAR Method with Depth
The STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) is an invaluable tool in interviews, especially for sharing impactful examples of your achievements. For executives, however, it is essential to go beyond the basics of STAR and focus on telling your story with depth and purpose. Select examples that showcase your leadership philosophy, strategic approach, problem-solving style and critical thinking abilities.
For instance, when discussing a complex project, paint a picture of the context - what challenges did the organisation face? What unique approach did you take? Illustrate the value of your contributions in a way that shows not only what you achieved but also how you achieved it. This storytelling approach keeps your responses authentic and engaging, allowing the interviewer to see both your technical and interpersonal strengths along with your ability to convey important information succinctly.
4. Maintain Control over Nerves and Emotions
Executive interviews are understandably high-stakes and it is natural to feel nervous, excited, anticipation, confident, curious, determines…. But managing your emotions is key to demonstrating executive presence. Begin by arriving early - this shows punctuality and gives you a few moments to settle, review your notes and get into the right mindset. Ensure you have three or four solid examples for each of the key requirements for the position (as laid out in the PD / Executive Briefing Document).
Take deep breaths, stay mindful of your body language and remind yourself of your strengths and experience. Remember that this interview is a dialogue, not an interrogation. Your calm demeanour, even under pressure, reflects your readiness for leadership.
5. Do Your Homework: Research with Intention
Preparing for an executive interview means going beyond the company’s website and press releases. Take a deep dive into the organisation’s Annual Report (or equivalent) specifically it’s financial statements, organisational and Board structure, directors report and any previous or pending projects of note.
6. Show Enthusiasm and Positivity
Leaders are not only hired for their skills but also for their energy and outlook. Bring a positive and enthusiastic attitude to your interview, emphasising your excitement about the company and role. Highlight what drives you, the reasons you are passionate about the field and your eagerness to contribute to the organisation’s goals. This energy can be contagious and hiring managers are drawn to leaders who inspire confidence and optimism.
Keep in mind that the selection panel has already been impressed enough, by your skills and technical abilities on screen / paper, to invite you to interview. During the interview you must build on this but also determine if there is a cultural fit between you and the organisation. Your communication style, professional approach, chemistry with the panel, mannerisms, values, confidence, vision for the organisations future… help the interviewers create a better understanding of the complete you and your ‘fit’.
7. Prepare Strategic Questions: Show Insight and Engagement
A well-prepared executive brings thoughtful, strategic questions to the table. Prepare four or five questions focused on the organisation’s goals, current challenges and team dynamics. Here are some examples:
“What are the key strategic priorities for the team over the next 12 months?”
“How does the leadership team envision adapting to industry changes in the coming years?”
“Can you share more about the team I would be working with and the strengths they bring?”
“How do you see this role contributing to the organisation’s long-term mission?”
These questions reflect your forward-thinking mindset, understanding of organisational strategy, interest in understanding the ‘whole story’ and genuine curiosity about the role’s impact on the company’s success.
8. Conclude with Confidence
As the interview draws to a close, thank the interviewers for their time, express your appreciation for the conversation, reiterate your enthusiasm and confirm the next step in the process for successful candidates.
A confident, positive close underscores your interest and leaves a lasting impression. The interview is your chance to share your achievements, vision and personality with people who could soon become your colleagues. Embrace the opportunity to build rapport, demonstrate your leadership and show that you’re not only qualified but the right cultural fit.
Mastering an executive interview requires more than polished answers; it is about showing who you are as a leader, from your professional expertise to your values and ambitions. By combining preparation with authenticity, engaging storytelling and a strategic approach, you’ll set yourself apart as a candidate who’s ready to lead and inspire.
Comments